Is your insurer any good? This online tool may help

May 02, 2012 By sherylsmolkin 


Insurance is something we buy just in case:  Last spring's flooding in St. Jean sur Richelieu, Que., when the Richelieu River  overflowed its banks.  (May 5, 2011)


Insurance  can seem like a waste of money until you need it. Then the policy proceeds are a welcome cushion, easing the  impact of unfortunate events. But with  premiums costing thousands  a year, it is not surprising that some consumers  think they are paying too much or believe poor service from their carrier..


A recent InsurEye Inc. survey of 1,500 people in Alberta, British Columbia, Quebec and Ontario reveals interesting attitudes towards insurance and understanding of what they're paying for.  For example:

0.60 per cent  believe they pay too much for home, auto, or life insurance.

0.32 per cent do not understand all the features of their current coverage.

0.22 per cent report that insurance companies/agents do not clearly explain their policy provisions.

0.45 per cent want to know how much peers pay for their insurance to better inform their own decisions.



When a selected panel of consumers were also asked to review home, auto and life insurance companies for the InsurEye Consumer experience platform, they had lots of other beefs about their insurers.


The six top complaints were:

1. Unfair handling of claims, including incorrect value estimation for insured car or home.

2. Increased insurance rates without any reason like accidents or after “not-at-fault”  accidents.

3.Slow claim processing (up to 9 months in some cases).

4. Rude insurance agents or call center personnel.

5. Lack of contact/insufficient help from customer service.

6. Threats that insurance rates will go up.


Related: Many insurers reject requests. Will yours?


Based on these research findings, InsurEye has developed a consumer-driven insurance review tool that allows Canadians to rate most insurers and their products across the country.


The recently-launched system already contains over 600 reviews collected online for home, auto and life insurers. The insurance companies are rated on three main criteria using a scale of one to five stars, including customer experience, value for money and claims experience. Consumer comments give reviews context and share valuable experiences.


Reading independent reviews is free  and registered users (no charge) can write reviews, rate insurers and vote for other reviews. All reviews are anonymous and before publishing, reviews are assessed by moderators to ensure the content quality.


I was pleased to see that my home and auto insurer TD Meloche Monnex has been reviewed by 22 people to date and received an overall rating of four out of five stars and 4.5 stars for claims experience.


I can  attest to the fact that the day I drove through the garage door several years ago and smashed a can of driveway sealant releasing irritating fumes, their service was unbelievable. Within hours of my call, guys in hazmat suits removed everything and did an inventory. Although garage contents from a snow blower to a garden hose had to be destroyed, I had a cheque in a couple of weeks based on estimates easily obtained online from retailers.


The more people who enter data into the system, the better the tool will be for everyone, so consider adding your ratings. After all, you check online reviews for travel destinations, restaurants and movies. It only makes sense to use an online resource to compare both price and service information about Canadian insurers.





Leave Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.